Our Store

Food & Grocery

We proudly serve Hershey's Hand Dipped Ice Cream. We offer 16 flavors that are constantly changing so make sure to come in and see what's available in the cabinet frequently. We also offer a unique twist on milkshakes - giving you the opportunity to choose your ice cream flavor(s) & your Till Top Creamery milk of choice.

The honey at Till Top is collected from bees our uncle keeps at our family farm. The honey is uncapped from the honeycomb, spun out in the extractor, and strained through a coarse screen to remove the big chunks of wax- that's it. We love the whole, natural honey that our honey bees work so hard to make for us to enjoy & hope you do too!

For over 125 years, Fuhrman’s Cider has been providing Erie and the surrounding areas with premium, small batch Apple Cider. Made with the freshest apples from our suppliers in Western Pennsylvania and New York, you can find Fuhrman's Apple Cider during the fall at Till Top. We carry all sizes: gallon, half gallon, and pint. Taste the difference!
*This product is only available seasonally.*

The Kipp's provide us with delicious homemade apple butter and grape juice concentrate from Chambersburg, PA. Zach Kipp's grandfather spent many of his days producing and selling his apple butter until the end of his life in 2002. Unfortunately, as with many family recipes, he never saw the need to write it down. To keep grandfather's legacy alive, Zach crafted his own recipe and system to carry on the legacy. Their grape juice is made using a steaming process that extracts the juice from freshly harvested Pennsylvania concord grapes. This juice is rich and bold. The recommended mixing ratio is 1:1 with water or for something extra special, mix with ginger ale instead. Hymns and Hers is keeping good things good!

Pearl Valley Cheese is a family-owned manufacturer of award winning natural cheeses located in Fresno, Ohio. They are renowned for their award-winning Swiss cheese. In addition to the traditional Swiss, they also produce a variety of Colby, Marble, and Cheddar cheese.
Pearl Valley Cheese also provides us with Amish Country's finest butter, that is hand rolled, by real people, into wax paper.

Peterson's Candies of Busti, NY specialize in a variety of delicious chocolates. All of the confections of theirs that we carry are made on-site in their Candy Kitchen with locally-sourced materials.
During the holiday season, Peterson's supplies with hand-rolled candy canes as well.
*Most of these products are only available seasonally.*

The stewards of Quiet Creek Herb Farm, located in Brookville, PA, focus their mission on increasing public awareness of conservation, ecological thinking, and healthful sustainable living. Lush gardens of organic vegetables, herbs, and edible flowers stretch across their farm, allowing them to craft a variety of all-natural products. Stop by Till Top for a variety of Quiet Creek's loose leaf teas, salves, and seasonings.

Alan's mom, Lisa, always wanted chickens and Till Top was in need of an egg supplier so the Royek chicken coop #1 was purchased. Due to high demand, coop #2 was built. Lisa's 34 Golden comet layers give us brown eggs. Most of them are large or extra large on the egg scale and are handwashed. We are proud to offer (very) farm fresh eggs - right from the Royek farm daily!

Solid-View Farms, located in Titusville, PA, is owned by Jake and Casey Jones. They started their 100 acre farm in 2021, focusing on raising pigs, cows, and their own row crops including wheat, corn, and oats. Their main focus is raising delicious local pork products.

Steel Toe Farm, located in Girard, PA, has been raising chickens and other animals on their small farm since 2019. They pride themselves in providing their animals with locally sourced feed to provide the best food possible for the local community. Their chickens spend their days in mobile tractors making their way around their pasture, fertilizing the soil, and absorbing the earth's nutrients, just as nature intended until they are ready for your dinner table!

Our neighboring friends at Sweet Traditions tap trees right in Corry, many of which are located on our family farm. Sweet Traditions is much more than maple syrup - they offer maple cream, maple cotton candy, various maple coated nuts, & many more sweet maple treats!

Delicious homemade sourdough bread is freshly baked weekly from The Park Coffe & Bread Co., located in Lawrence Park. Kristen and team make a variety of sourdough loaves including: Plain, Jalapeño Cheddar, Pepperoni Mozzarella, Cinnamon Sugar, Olive, Garlic Parmesan, Cranberry Goat Cheese, and Herb & Cheese. These loaves are vailable for weekly pre-order with delivey to the Creamery Wednesday late afternoon/early evening.

Al-By Farm, located in Union City, PA, began milking LaMancha goats in 2012. Soon after, they began making all-natural goat's milk soap. They strive to use ingredients that are readily available, sustainable, and sourced as local as possible. Their products are made with pure essential oils. They feel great about what's in their products and you can too. Lather up!

BS Expressions, of The Apple Basket of North East, is a family owned business that provides quality personalized products. They can apply your design to products with various methods including silk screening, sublimation, and vinyl. Our Till Top Creamery t-shirts and mugs are personalized courtesy of them.
"Let us help you express yourself in designing the perfect apparel or personalized gifts."

Double K Leather creates numerous leather goods. Leather goods that you can find in Till Top Creamery are leather earrings, hair clips, wallets, and wristlets. Contact Kyra through facebook if you would like something custom made to your liking.

Fibers from the alpacas at Gramma's Orchard Alpaca Farm, located in Union City, are used to make socks. These socks are available in a variety of different weights - from the Backpaca as a great lightweight hiking sock to the heavyweight Outdoorsman that are great for keeping your feet warm!
*These products are only available seasonally.*

Local artist, Pat, designs a variety of intricate greeting cards. Pat's creative, unique cards are available for a variety of occasions including: thank you, sympathy, wedding/anniversary, get well, birthday, encouragement, thinking of you, a simple hello, and even blanks.
These handmade with love greeting cards are one of a kind for your special someone!

Melissa's artist abilities are displayed in these beautifully handpainted saws. These are available in a variety of sizes and designs as a perfect gift.
*These products are only available seasonally.*

Corry native, Jackie Reynolds (Pondel), is a children's book author, entertainer, and professional clown. Some of her books, including: Springtime, Bee Bee's Circus at the Counting Fair, and Bee Bee's Circus Number Fun: Activity Book, are available at the Creamery!

Sally Pondel provides us with multiple unique laser cut wood crafts, ranging from refrigerator magnets, signs, key holders, Christmas ornaments, and other handcrafted items. Sally's unique artist abilities are witnessed in every item crafted.

Local crocheter, Stacy Parks, provides us with a variety of handmade items. Year round, the Creamery is stocked with dish scrubbies, dish cloths, and two sizes of hot pads. Seasonally, Stacy crafts other items as well.